The Orthodontics Professors
  • Latest
  • Think Pieces
  • About
  • Contact
  • Resources
  • Latest
  • Think Pieces
  • About
  • Contact
  • Resources

T{o}P
The Orthodontics Professors

the latest in contemporary & evidence-based orthodontics

Are Orthodontists Better at Invisalign®? A Survey of General Dentists and Orthodontists Says. . .

1/13/2017

1 Comment

 
PicturePicture from Best et al. General Dentists were more confident in treating this case, but also less likely, in general, to use Class II elastics with Invisalign®.
BY TATE H. JACKSON AND WILLIAM V. GIERIE

STUDY SYNOPSIS
A study in the Angle Orthodontist has surveyed 1,000 General Dentists and 1,000 Orthodontists – drawn from a list of Invisalign® providers on the company’s website. Those surveyed were asked to rate their confidence using Invisalign® to treat six different cases for which intra-oral photographs were provided: a Deep Bite case, a Posterior Crossbite case, a Anterior Open Bite case, Mild Crowding case, a Severe Crowding case, and a Class II case. Additionally, both Orthodontists and General Dentists were asked about their various treatment planning (e.g. time spent with ClinChecks) and mechanics (e.g. use of Class II elastics or auxiliaries) tendencies with Invisalign®. Finally, demographic and training information, as well as experience in treating cases with Invisalign® was reported.

Overall, both Orthodontists and General Dentists were relatively confident in treating the four cases presented with Invisalign®. Interestingly, General Dentists were significantly more confident when it came to more complex cases: deep bite, severe crowding, and Class II. Orthodontists reported higher confidence in treating mild crowding than General Dentists.
 
Orthodontists were significantly more likely to spend more time reviewing ClinCheck set-ups and were more likely to use refinements and elastics as a part of treatment. Not surprisingly, Orthodontists reported more training and experience using Invisalign® and were more likely than General Dentists to tell patients that their malocclusion was too complex for Invisalign®.

PictureDr. William V. Gierie

WHAT THE PROFESSORS THINK
This article provides some data for practicing Orthodontists that might be of great use in discussing with patients why orthodontic care is specialized treatment – not just the appliance used to straighten teeth.
 
The use of a specific case records in conjunction with confidence ratings, and not just a survey self-report, gives these data some greater credibility. The use of intra-oral photographs alone had good rationale, since it provided a realistic version of the information that a General Dentist might consider when planning an Invisalign® case. The structure of the survey, asking respondents to give demographic and training information after completing the confidence ratings is helpful since it aids in avoiding bias when reporting confidence.

The fact that the response rate to the survey is not clearly reported is an unfortunate shortcoming of the study – one that, if clarified, would significantly improve the reliability of the results.
 
There are two pieces of information from this study that are most interesting and clinically relevant:
  1. General Dentists reported a higher level of confidence in treating more complex cases but also reported using auxiliaries less often. For example, General Dentists used Class II elastics less often than Orthodontists but reported a higher confidence in treating the Class II case. Together, these results suggest a lack of expertise for General Dentists.
  2. Orthodontists were more likely to have more training, to have treated more Invisalign® cases overall and in the past 12 months, to spend more time adjusting ClinCheck set-ups, and to use more refinements than General Dentists. All of these points suggest that Orthodontists not only might have more training and experience, but also that they might put more effort in to achieving a more ideal final result.

Article Reviewed: Best et al. Treatment management between orthodontist and general practitioners performing clear aligner therapy. Angle Orthodontist. Online Early Nov 2016.







1 Comment
Alexandra Best
4/24/2017 06:20:34 pm

Dear Drs Jackson and Gierie, I just wanted to mention that this article is now available in Angle's May edition, and it includes a paragraph that was accidentally deleted from the earlier online version reviewed above. That missing paragraph discusses the response rate, which was critical to the results as noted in the review. "Responses were received from 374 orthodontists and 229 general dentists, for a response rate of 37% and 23%, respectively." Thank you!

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    RSS Feed

    Curated by:

    Tate H. Jackson, DDS, MS
    with
    Tung T. Nguyen, DMD, MS
    ​

    Categories

    All

    Archives

    October 2019
    July 2019
    March 2019
    January 2019
    October 2018
    September 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    January 2017
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016

The Orthodontics Professors

Copyright © 2016